ODAC Won’t Make Guilford Forfeit BC Win (Daily News-Record)
Daily News-Record - by Jeremy Cothran
BRIDGEWATER — Guilford College used an ineligible player in its victory over Bridgewater on Oct. 14, the Old Dominion Athletic Conference said Monday, but Eagles fans shouldn’t get too excited: ODAC Commissioner Brad Bankston said the league has decided not to penalize the Quakers, meaning they won’t have to forfeit any wins unless the NCAA decides otherwise.
Had BC been awarded the victory, the Eagles would have been back in the championship race.
"The [ODAC] committee reviewed all the materials," Bankston said from Salem. "We will take no action against Guilford. We are proceeding with a secondary violation process and we’ll submit papers with Guilford to a representative with the NCAA."
An NCAA decision, however, is not expected to be handed down until after the regular season ends.
Last week, Emory & Henry football coach Don Montgomery said, he informed the ODAC that the Quakers were using a transfer, cornerback Dion Rich, who had been declared academically ineligible after the 2005 season at E&H.
Montgomery said Rich flunked out of Emory & Henry in the middle of October, and then enrolled at Guilford this fall. Bankston said because Rich was ineligible when he left E&H, he also was ineligible when he enrolled at Guilford.
The league decided against disciplining Guilford, Bankston said, because it determined that the Greensboro, N.C., school did not know Rich was ineligible. But, he said, the ODAC plans to report the incident to the NCAA’s enforcement committee, which could opt to punish the Quakers.
That process, however, would probably take about a month – which would be too late for Bridgewater to be considered for the NCAA Division III playoffs.
Fifth-place Bridgewater (6-2 overall, 2-2 in the league) lost to Guilford 33-28, the first of two consecutive defeats that likely cost the five-time defending champion a realistic shot at the ODAC title. Rich had six tackles in the Quakers’ win.
"I had a pep talk with my players and I told them that you learn lessons," Clark said. "We talk all the time, and you can’t count on committees. It’s all about managing your business. We didn’t, so it doesn’t matter who was on the field. That’s kind of where it stands."
Bankston said the ODAC considered three options: 1) forfeiture for all the games Rich participated in this fall, 2) vacating the games – meaning they would be stricken from Guilford’s record but would not affect the records of any teams the Quakers played, and 3) doing nothing.
In the end, the ODAC decided Guilford was not at fault for Rich’s enrollment and participation in football games.
Clark said his players were disappointed when he informed them that the Quakers would not be forced to forfeit.
"That was another pin I put in their balloons," he said.
Montgomery said he agreed with the league’s ruling, but he said coaches need to be more aware of the eligibility issues concerning incoming players.
"It’s the first time in my 30 years of coaching that I’ve seen something like this," Montgomery said, referring to Rich’s ability to re-enroll at a competitor’s school after flunking. "I think it’s all of our responsibilities. You have got to be eligible from the school that you’re leaving from. Got to find out."
Montgomery said he learned of Rich’s participation in games this year while viewing tape in preparation for the Wasps’ game against Bridgewater on Oct. 21. Rich, a sophomore from Martinsville, played in four games this season for the Quakers.
"Somebody on our staff pointed it out," Montgomery said. "I saw his name when he made a tackle on [Eagles tailback] Winston Young. He’s on their roster. That’s against NCAA and ODAC rules. If you’re going to have rules, then people have to abide by them."
Emory & Henry plays Guilford on Nov. 11.
Guilford officials could not be reached for comment.